New York Governor Kathy Hochul convened a series of high-profile meetings on Tuesday with key political figures as she considers taking the unprecedented step of removing New York City Mayor Eric Adams from office. The discussions come in response to mounting concerns over Adams’ ability to govern independently following the Justice Department’s controversial decision to drop its corruption case against him.
Hochul met with influential Black leaders and other top officials, including U.S. Rep. Hakeem Jeffries, City Comptroller Brad Lander, City Council Speaker Adrienne Adams, Rev. Al Sharpton, and U.S. Rep. Gregory Meeks. These discussions signal a growing consensus among Democratic powerbrokers that Adams’ tenure may be untenable.
The Fallout from Adams’ Legal Troubles
Mayor Eric Adams’ political crisis escalated dramatically following the Justice Department’s decision to dismiss bribery and other charges against him. The move, seen as an effort to secure his cooperation with President Donald Trump’s controversial immigration crackdown, raised serious ethical and legal concerns.
Adams had been under federal investigation since late 2023, with prosecutors scrutinizing his 2021 campaign fundraising activities. His troubles intensified when his electronic devices were seized in November, and several key aides resigned in connection with the probe. The indictment accused Adams of accepting illicit campaign donations and providing political favors to the Turkish government in return for luxury trips and other benefits.
While Adams has denied any wrongdoing and claimed he was being politically targeted for his criticism of President Joe Biden’s immigration policies, his shifting political alliances—including a closer relationship with Donald Trump—have further complicated his position within the Democratic Party.
Governor Hochul’s Political Dilemma
Despite having the legal authority to remove Mayor Adams, Governor Hochul has hesitated, citing concerns over the democratic process and the potential legal ramifications of such a move. However, the situation took a dramatic turn on Monday night when four of Adams’ top deputies abruptly resigned, prompting Hochul to question the viability of his administration.
Her decision-making process appears to be guided by discussions with top New York officials. Following his meeting with Hochul, Rev. Al Sharpton stated that the governor is waiting to see the outcome of a critical court hearing on Wednesday before making a final decision. However, some Democratic leaders, including Comptroller Brad Lander, have signaled their willingness to take action if Adams does not present a clear plan to stabilize his administration by the end of the week.
City Council Speaker Adrienne Adams, on the other hand, has cautioned against premature removal, arguing that such a step should be reserved for mayors who are physically or mentally incapacitated. Queens Borough President Donovan Richards has urged Adams to deeply reflect on whether he can continue serving effectively.
The Complex Process of Removing a Mayor
Should Governor Hochul decide to move forward with Adams’ removal, she would have to initiate a legally complex and unprecedented process. One option is to file official charges against the mayor and allow him a formal defense in what would effectively be a court-like proceeding.
Alternatively, a rarely invoked mechanism known as the “committee on inability” could be used. This panel, consisting of five city officials—including three Hochul has already consulted—would have the power to remove Adams if they determine he is unable to perform his duties. However, this process has never been implemented in New York City history, and there is little legal precedent for how it would unfold.
While some officials, including Lander, have expressed openness to convening the committee, others remain skeptical about the feasibility of such an action. The mayor’s allies argue that removal via this process could set a dangerous precedent and trigger prolonged legal battles.
Adams Remains Defiant Amid Calls for Resignation
Despite the mounting pressure, Mayor Adams has refused to step down, maintaining a defiant stance in the face of criticism. At a Tuesday press conference regarding a police detective’s shooting, Adams declined to address the growing calls for his resignation.
When pressed by reporters on why he had not spoken publicly in weeks, he responded sharply: “‘Cause y’all liars.” His comments further underscore the tension between City Hall and the press, as well as his growing isolation from both political allies and the broader public.
As the situation unfolds, the next 48 hours could prove pivotal in determining Adams’ political fate. Governor Hochul’s decision, expected after the Wednesday court hearing, could mark a historic turning point for New York City governance—either reinforcing Adams’ grip on power or paving the way for his removal.
